Starting off a new series of posts on Family Law topics, today I look at grounds for divorce in England and Wales, Scotland, and Spain, to learn about similarities and differences. This article provides a general overview of the grounds for divorce in each jurisdiction, followed by a comparison table which will help you remember the key points.
Grounds for divorce in England and Wales
Divorce in England and Wales is currently governed by the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973. Section 1(1) provides that:
Subject to section 3 below, a petition for divorce may be presented to the court by either party to a marriage on the ground that the marriage has broken down irretrievably. (Emphasis added)
The petitioner must prove the permanent breakdown of the marriage by satisfying the court of at least one of five available facts, established in section 1(2):
- Adultery. The respondent has committed adultery and the petitioner finds it intolerable to continue living with the respondent.
- Unreasonable behaviour. The respondent has behaved in such a way that the petitioner cannot be expected to live with the respondent. The Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 does not define ‘unreasonable behaviour’ but examples could include threats, physical violence, or drunkenness.
- Desertion. The respondent has abandoned the petitioner for at least two years immediately before the petition for divorce.
- Two years’ separation. The spouses have lived apart for at least two years and both spouses agree to the divorce.
- Five years’ separation. The spouses have lived apart for at least five years and one spouse does not agree to the divorce.
This means that, even in cases where spouses mutually agree to the divorce, proof that the marriage has irretrievably broken down (two years’ separation) is still required. Moreover, petitions for divorce can only be presented to the court after a couple has been married for a year.
A Bill (Divorce, Dissolution and Separation Bill [HL] 2019-21) entered Parliament on 7 January 2020. This new legislation seeks to reduce unnecessary family conflict and proposes big changes, such as replacing the requirement to give a fact (about behaviour or separation) with a statement of breakdown, abolishing the ability to contest a divorce, and allowing joint applications for divorce. Check the progress of the Bill through Parliament.
Grounds for divorce in Scotland
Divorce in Scotland is governed by the Divorce (Scotland Act 1976). Section 1(1) provides:
In an action for divorce the court may grant decree of divorce if, but only if, it is established in accordance with the following provisions of this Act that
(a) the marriage has broken down irretrievably or
(b) subject to subsection (3B), an interim gender recognition certificate under the Gender Recognition Act 2004 has, after the date of the marriage, been issued to either party to the marriage.
The pursuer (the Scottish equivalent of the English petitioner) can prove the permanent breakdown of the marriage by satisfying the court of at least one of four available facts:
- Adultery on the part of the defender (the Scottish equivalent of the English respondent).
- Unreasonable behaviour. The respondent has behaved in such a way that the petitioner cannot be expected to live with the respondent.
- One year separation. The spouses have lived apart for at least one year, and both spouses agree to the divorce.
- Two years’ separation. The spouses have lived apart for at least two years, and one spouse does not agree to the divorce.
Like in England and Wales, even in cases where spouses mutually agree to the divorce, proof that the marriage has irretrievably broken down is still required. However, when both spouses agree to the divorce, they can file a petition for divorce after one year of separation, unlike in England and Wales, where a two years’ separation is required.
Moreover, petitions for divorce can only be presented to the court after a couple has been married for a year, except where there is unreasonable behaviour or adultery.
Grounds for divorce in Spain
Artículo 86 Código Civil states:
Irrespective of how a marriage was solemnised, divorced will be granted by the court at the petition of one spouse, both spouses, or one spouse with the consent of the other, provided that the requirements and circumstances established by artículo 81 are met. (My own English translation. Not official.)
The said requirements and circumstances established by artículo 81 Código Civil vary, depending on whether divorce is by mutual consent (consensual) or defended (contencioso):
Divorce by mutual consent
Divorce will be granted by the court at the petition of both spouses, or one of them with the consent of the other, after at least three months have passed since the marriage took place.
Divorce may be granted not only by the court but also by decree from a court clerk (letrado de la Administración de Justicia) or by notarial instrument to spouses filing for divorce by mutual consent, provided that there are no non-emancipated children or children adjudicated incompetent (Ley 15/2015, de Jurisdicción Voluntaria, which amended artículo 87 Código Civil).
Divorce will be granted by the court at the petition of one spouse, after at least three months have passed since the marriage took place, unless the spouse or their children are at risk.
Unlike the current requirements in England and Wales, and Scotland, having to allege grounds for divorce is not required when filing for divorce in Spain, and spouses can file a petition as early as three months after getting married.
Spanish divorce proceedings – whether defended or by mutual consent – are always no-fault, unlike divorces in England and Wales, and Scotland. There is no need to prove that a spouse is at fault, and divorce is not seen as a punishment to the spouse at fault. As stated on the explanatory statement (exposición de motivos) of Ley 15/2005, the Spanish divorce system aims to highlight the freedom of spouses during marriage, as living together and the duration of marriage depend on the continuous will of both spouses (Ley 15/2008). Not willing to be married to someone is sufficient cause for filing a petition for divorce.
The information included in this article is correct at the time of publication/last update. This article is for informational purposes only, does not constitute legal advice and should not be relied upon as such. Any reliance you place on such information is strictly at your own risk. ICR Translations will not be liable for any loss or damage arising from loss of data or profits as a result of, or in connection with, the use of this website.
IRENE CORCHADO RESMELLA is a Spanish translator based in Edinburgh. A Chartered Linguist and member of the CIOL, she is also an English-Spanish sworn translator appointed by the Spanish Ministry of Foreign Affairs. Irene specialises in sworn and legal translation (particularly in wills and succession) and is an Affiliate member of STEP. ICR Translations is registered with the Information Commissioner's Office and has professional indemnity insurance.